DS-Scene www.ds-scene.net
  Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )
 
 
 »  
DS-Scene » Forum Index » DS-Scene Official Hardware Reviews » R4DS Version Comparison - Read the official comparison inside.
Get Adobe Flash player
 
         
 
 
 » DS-Scene Official Hardware Reviews
 
     
  R4DS Version Comparison - Read the official comparison inside.
Posted by retrohead on Thu, February 22nd, 2007 at 17:19 - 4 Comments
 
multi
options
retrohead United Kingdom

 
R4DS Version Comparison





Introduction

It is a known fact that the R4DS is the same hardware as the M3 DS Simply and it was discovered that the original cards could be modified into the other and vice versa. The R4DS Team updated the hardware for both products which now stops the alteration being made along with bundling a different selection of goodies in the box. The question we all want answered is are these devices any different between versions.

To help answer any questions, Samad at ModMyDS sent me a sample of the R4DS version 2 to compare against the first model (you can read the official ds-scene review of the R4DS v1 here)



Contents Comparison


Version 1

Version 2


Opening the box, you are greeted with a slightly different selection of contents compared the the original release of the R4DS. You still get the CD, USB reader/writer and the carry case for 2 DS cards but they are different compared to the original ones. I will explain the differences in this comparison and let you know whether I think the new product is better or worse than the old one.


Carry Case Comparison

Version 1 Version 2

Version 1 Version 2


The small carry case that was included with the original release (left) makes a welcome return for the newer model of the R4DS but is clearly a different brand. The quality of this new case (right) does seem a little inferior (cheaper) to it's predecessor. The DS cards do not seem to fit as tightly into the rubber holder and the case just feels alot less heavy duty than the original. The first sign of a cost saving excercise?


USB Reader/Writer Comparison

Version 1 Version 2


The new USB reader seems a hell of alot better than the older one. The casing for the USB reader is alot more sturdy with no sign of creaking or falling apart like the first version and it's general use seems to be alot better aswell with no problems encountered with the microSD card not being recongised or similar. It does, for some reason, seem to be a cheaper brand though but of course we all know that it is functionality that matters.


CD Comparison


Version 1

Version 2


The CD contents are exactly the same as the previous version. I would have expected to see at least a copy of the latest shell included but all you get is the first version and everything else you got (rom trimmmer etc). The CD does seem to be a different brand though with the label being more matt where as the first one had more of a glossy finish. Perhaps another sign of cost saving.

Apart from the details I mentioned above, there is nothing else different with the newer CD.



Shell(s) Comparison

Version 1 Version 2


The shells when compared match exactly. The labels, card quality and the shape of the mold are identical. You may notice I said shells rather than shell, well spotted if you did because the v2 models come packaged with a single shell alone but my sample came with the usual 2 shells. I have been told that because of the demand for the R4, they stopped producing the 2nd shell temporarily to use the labor towards producing more R4's. M3 comes in the gray shell and R4 in the white one :)



PCB Comparison


Version 1

Version2


Comparing the PCB's, they appear to be exactly the same high quality that you expect to see inside your R4. The spring loaded micro SD slot seems to be exactly the same for the samples I recieved, contrary to belief. Of course the v2 seems to pack more of a punch with the spring but I would say this is down to me having worn the v1 model during my review and game playing habits since. The major changes are a slight modification to the of the board and minor component changes.


Version 1

Version2


There is of course the main update to the board. These are close up images of the boards which clearly show where the contacts have been removed from the PCB on the new model. There is now no way for you to modify the board into an M3 device but that's how it should have been at first right?


Performance Comparison

Not alot to say in this section. The card performs exactly the same as the first model with no differences found in compatibility at all. You can check out or review of the R4DS v1 for a small breakdown on compatibility,


Conclusion

The lack of the extra shell does leave a sour taste in the mouth though the increased functionality of the USB reader is like a breath of fresh air after the first version. I would have preferred to still recieve the first DS card carry case though it is still nice to recieve something like this at all.

You can't help feeling that there should have perhaps been a slight decrease in price with the newer version of the R4DS, though the compatibility is exaclty the same as the first model so you cannot really complain.

Overall the R4DS v2 is an excellent card and I would highly recommend it to anyone looking to purchase a new slot 1 solution though the whole experience of opening the box and admiring the contents was a little toned down with the v2 model.




DS-Scene would like to thank ModMyDS for sending us a sample of the R4DS for reviewing purposes. Check out ModMyDS for all some great deals on the flashcards reviewed on ds-scene


Here is some great news DS-Scene users save 5% on all orders! Enter code DS-SCENE during checkout :)





 
 Signature
 
 » Comment On: - R4DS Version Comparison
#1
 
SkinnyV Canada

  Fri, February 23rd, 2007 at 01:28
top
multi
options
 
Just want to let you guys know that there is apparently a third revision with the language pad removed just like they removed the conversion pad. So be careful if you did like me and ordered the chinese version thinking you would be able to switch it to english to save a few buck, I was lucky and got the second revision but you might not be this lucky:P

I finaly found a picture proving this on fatwallet.com:




Some dude found a way of doing the language mod even with the third revision but I don't advice people to try to do the same as it is a ''really'' risky process and you can easily use the chinese version without undertanding chinese at all.




Original thread for discussion about it is:

http://www.fatwallet.com/forums/messageview.php?start=420&catid=18&threadid=698220

*edited on 2007/02/23 01:52:03 by SkinnyV

*edited on 2007/02/23 01:55:28 by SkinnyV
 
 Signature
 
 » Comment On: - R4DS Version Comparison
#2
 
Vaskituh Portugal

  Sat, February 24th, 2007 at 19:24
top
multi
options
 
Thanks SkinnyV for telling us that! I thought i knew that, i think i read it on some other sites or something, but this is not an official revision, just a little modification they made without telling people.
 
 Signature
         
 


 
 » Users reading this topic.
 
 
1 user(s) are viewing this topic (1 Guests)
 

0 Members:
refresh



Home    Download    Forum    Release List    Reviews    RSS Feed    Search    Weblinks
Powered by FunkySkunk Forums v2 © 2007 retrohead - Exclusive to DS-Scene.net - irc.efnet.net #ds-scene 
 
Performed 11 Queries in 0.02871 Seconds. 
The page rendered in 0.95673 Seconds. 
www.ds-scene.net